|
Ohio: The "Ohio portion" of the "pre-1979" chart, as printed last quarter: |
|
|
|
1. First, for comparison, the "Ohio part", as printed in the last issue: |
|
1. William Nelson [m] Margaret Holderbaum 2. Samuel | 1. John 3. Elisha | 2. Calvin born O., Calvin's children: 4. John | 3. Edward " " | Hubert 5. ? | 4. Tokea | John | 5. Martha | George W. b.1863 Youngstown,O. | 6. George | m. Margaret Teagarten | 7. William | 1. John N. m. ___?__ ___?__ | 2. James O. | 1. Nelson | 3. William | 2. John N. Jr. | 4. George Jr. | 3. Margaret | 5.,6.,7.,8., Ruth |
|
2. Second, it seems clear that this chart refers to the "three brothers" John, Henry, and William, of Allegheny River in western Pennsylvania. |
|
|
|
3. Third, I now believe that the first two lines of the Ohio chart, with the two names standing alone, probably do not mean “William Henry [McAninch]”, as I wrote in that issue, but, instead, probably mean that the researcher had second-generation and third-generation names, but didn't know which of the two (non-John) brothers to put the children with; also, he/she had no info on wives. |
|
|
|
4. Fourth, two people (Dorothy Goudy McAninch and James F. McAninch) report that George W.'s father's name was William, and that it was that particular William who was married to Margaret Holderbaum. |
|
|
|
5. Thus, a current re-cast of the "Ohio portion" might be as follows: |
|
William [or] Henry [brothers of John (who stayed in Pennsylvania)] |
|
_______ _____ [Spouse(s) Unknown] |
|
|
|
Second Third |
|
Generation: Generation: |
|
1. William 1. John |
|
2. Samuel 2. Calvin born O., Calvin's children: |
|
3. Elisha 3. Edward " " | Hubert |
|
4. John 4. Tokea | John |
|
5. ? 5. Martha | George (?) |
|
6. George |
|
7. William [m] Margaret Holderbaum |
|
| William |
|
| George W. b.1863 m. Margaret Teagarten |
|
| 1. John Nelson. m. Carolyn Lee Hoffman |
|
| 2. James O. | 1. Nelson |
|
6. Question -- | 3. William | 2. Margaret Ruth |
|
which William was | 4. George Jr. | 3. John J. |
|
William Nelson McA.? | 5.,6....see below |
|
7. There sure are a lot of William McAninch's and George McAninch's! |
|
McAninch Family History Newsletter, Vol. II, No. 2, May 1994 pg. 7 page 1994-16 |
|
|
|
[original contents (except as noted); change font for online presentation (May 2003)] |