Enlisting in the CEF, he becomes a sniper. Ian learns to play the Highland bagpipes and becomes

entangled with two girls whom he meets in the Highland heart of Nova Scotia. Although horrified

at the atrocities of war, Ian enlists as a piper when assured that he will be able to play in the pipe

band and not have to kill. Fraser, the lighthearted one, occupies himself with girls until he joins his

brothers in their army adventures.

 

The contingents of the CEF sent to England are referred to as the “comedian contingents”

by Imperial Army officers who proceed to forge the intrepid Canucks into effective soldiers.

Shipped to the Western Front, Sable and his brothers experience bombardments, trench raids,

entombment, mine explosions, sniping, bayonet fighting, firefights, loss of comrades, barroom

brawls, bloody disasters, mud and mayhem while in the ranks of the 25th Battalion, Nova Scotia

Rifles (The MacKenzie Highlanders) as well as the 31st Battalion of Calgary. Sable undergoes

intensive sniper training and takes his toll on the enemy. Ian becomes a stretcher-bearer and a

brother keeper of his battalion mates. Experiencing the horrors of the Imperial Army’s first day

of slaughter on the Somme, Ian loses his faith in a compassionate God.

 

The paths of the brothers diverge and cross. The Canadians succeed under British general

Sir Julian Byng in their assault on Vimy Ridge where Ian pipes his battalion mates “over the top”

and arouses the ‘mir cath’, or frenzy of battle, among the men. Tempered in the fiery furnace

of combat, they experience the major battles of the war. The Corps goes on to fight in the

“bloody bog of Passchendaele,” successful under Canadian General Sir Arthur Currie. During

the agony of battle, Fraser and Ian make a mutual, mercy-killing pact. By 1918 the Canadians

have become an elite corps of shock troops second to none on the Western Front; together

with the Australian Corps, they spearhead the first major breakthrough of the war at Amiens.

It is here that the orders of a drunken officer destroy the brother keepers.

 

This saga of military tragedy and heroism explores the Highland military tradition,

reveals resonances to modern day wars and engages the moral and religious issues of war as it

postulates “The Iron Corollary to the Golden Rule.” Mysterious, even unworldly, persons weave

their way through the pages, seemingly shadowing the MacInnes boys. “The Brother Keepers”

is a story of faith lost and faith maintained, doublethink, elusive love, the sanctity of brotherhood

and the toll of warfare interspersed with interludes of humor. Out of this searing odyssey on

European soil, the most significant event in Canadian history, emerged worldwide recognition

of the Canadian Corps and Canada as a nation unto itself .

 

About the Author: Currently residing in Old Saybrook, Connecticut, Dr. John E. (Ted) MacNintch

is a former native of Maritime Canada with strong Nova Scotia roots. He became interested in the

history of the involvement of five of his relatives in the Great War and in the Scottish military

tradition in Canada while employed as Director of Scientific Information for Bristol-Myers Squibb.

Upon retirement, he applied his scientific information-retrieval and writing skills to researching

World War I over a ten-year period in an effort to create a novel that is entertaining, emotional and

very informative with special emphasis on verisimilitude. He spends his summers with his wife Joan,

writing, boating and kayaking in the Thousand Islands region of Upper New York State.

 

_________________________________________________________________________

McAninch Family History NL v.XV n.3 / July 2007 / Frank McAninch, Editor / page 2007-20

 

Table of Contents for this Year

First Page of this Issue

Previous Page

Next Page