History of Methodism at Coatesville, by Dr. Stephen Hunt |
“The history of Methodism at Coatesville [Note 1] begins with the history of the town, about the |
time the Van R.R. [Vandalia Railroad, Note 2] was laid out. . . . There were Methodists in this |
vicinity many years before Coatesville, but meetings were held at the private houses for the most |
part. Pleasant Hill [Note 3] on the South had been a church for 20 years or more when the class |
was organized here. |
Along about 1850 a preacher would occasionally appoint a meeting at Coatesville. . . . Dempsey |
Mendenhall, 1851, a Quaker, a brother to Nathan at Reno (and a bachelor) had just built a house |
and as it was unoccupied the Meth[odists] asked for it for holding meetings, he consented and the |
Quakers were about to church him, but he made his acknowledgment, as was their custom, |
and held his place. But when the Meth[odists] asked him the 2nd time for the house they got it. . . . |
There were not many houses in this place then and most of them were occupied by Quakers. |
It was the year ’51 that the Van R.R. [Vandalia Railroad] [sic] was built and the first train from |
T.H. [Terre Haute] to Indianapolis ran in Jan. ’52. Now about this time Lewis Roberts organized |
an M.E. [Methodist Episcopal] class for the people here. . . . |
[list of names] Francis A. Figg & wife, Wesley T. F. “ “ [& wife], Norman Dixon & wife, |
Nathan Meredith & wife, Jacob Mann & wife, I. Pierson & wife, Wm. H. Figg and perhaps others. |
Jeremiah Smith & wife not members of the 1st class, they with Hugh Wilson & wife soon became |
members of the class, and also Daniel McAninch Sen. & wife [Note 4]. Francis Asbury Figg was |
the class leader and Norman Dixon asst. [assistant] till about 1860. |
The first M.E. Church was dedicated in ’54 and the history rather uneventful for a time. |
Jesse Woodward was pastor when the new church ... was dedicated in ’64. The building of this |
church has quite a history. Some of the soldiers helped to get out the timbers before they volunteered. |
(Chas. Green framed the building 61-64) and after serving the whole time came back in time for the |
dedication. The frame was put up, stood there for 2 or 3 years then was very much damaged by a |
storm. Finally completed, then dedicated in ’65. [sic, as written, “64” in first line, and “65” here /fm] |
After Asbury Figg, Jacob Millman was class leader for several years. We don’t know just how many |
years. Father Grimes was made class leader in 1865 and was leader for 15 years till 1880.” [Note 5,6] |
Source: “History of Methodism at Coatesville”, by Dr. Stephen Hunt, 7 pages, copied from original |
manuscript [no date given] by Mary R. Hunt, 1971, typed by Mina Emily Seidler, 4/6/71; Plainfield |
Public Library, Plainfield, Indiana, H977.253 H943h H2408, “gift of Mary Fisher Hunt, 4/14/71”. |
Original manuscript written after 1880, in late 1800’s or very early 1900’s, based on references to |
“a few of the first class still live” and “Father Grimes wrote” [my estimate, Frank McAninch] |
Notes: |
[1] Methodist Episcopal Church, Coatesville, McAninch F.H.NL, Vol.VI, No.1, Jan.1998, p.8 |
[2] Vandalia Railroad, later part of the Pennsylvania Railroad; line is now abandoned (1998) |
[3] refers to [Old] Pleasant Hill Methodist Episcopal Church and Cemetery, in Franklin Twp., |
Hendricks County; Cemetery article, McAninch F.H.NL, Vol. V, No. 4, Nov. 1997, pg. 31. |
[4] Daniel McAninch, “Senior”, and wife, Phebe (Pike) McA., parents of Daniel A. McAninch |
[5] Jacob Millman, class leader, later “joined Radical Methodists” [church records, Note 1]; |
Daniel A. and Rhoda (Wilson) McA. also “joined Radical Methodists” (was this in 1865?) |
[6] is “Father Grimes” related to Elias Grimes, Trustee of Pleasant Hill M.E. Church? [Note 3] |
McAninch Family History NL, VI-4 October, 1998 Copyright Frank McAninch page 1998-34 |